Image

4:09 AM / Tuesday December 16, 2025

19 Feb 2016

After Supreme Court ruling, failure of state takeover and need for major reforms are clear

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
February 19, 2016 Category: Week In Review Posted by:

Councilwoman Helen Gym (At Large) released the following statement following yesterday’s Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s ruling in West Philadelphia Achievement Charter Elem. v. the School District of Philadelphia and SRC:

“Yesterday’s Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling makes unmistakably clear that the School Reform Commission and Pennsylvania’s fifteen-year experiment in state takeover have been a disaster for students and schools.”

“Since its formation, and particularly in recent years, the SRC has used its unprecedented powers to impose new rules that allow schools to operate without essential staff, slash programming, close schools, and violate key sections of the teachers’ contract. The SRC has also continued to recklessly expand the charter sector by approving new charters and ceding control of dozens of schools to private operators. Charter payments have rapidly become the District’s largest cost burden while underfunded, understaffed neighborhood schools languish in disrepair.”

“After years of administrative overreach and failed experimentation, with no end in sight to the ‘fiscal distress’ the Commission was supposed to alleviate, the time has come to dissolve the School Reform Commission and finally give control of Philadelphia’s schools to Philadelphians.”

“Furthermore, with the Court’s declaration that Harrisburg may not abdicate its responsibilities to the SRC, it has become urgently necessary for the General Assembly to fix the state’s broken system for funding and regulating public education. Specifically the legislature must address its deeply-flawed, nineteen-year old charter law, which prevents school districts from exercising full control over charter school authorization and growth. Without action, Philadelphia’s school district will not remain solvent and is at grave risk.”

“Both in Philadelphia and across the state, it is abundantly clear that our system of public schools, so many of which are struggling to provide the most basic services to students, cannot be called ‘thorough and efficient.’ It is now up to the Courts to weigh in on the need for a fair funding system, and to ensure that the legislature does its job.”

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Leave a Comment

Recent News

Philly NAACP

ACE-ing your health

December 2, 2025

Share Tweet Email Gathering and using data to make healthcare more equitable is the purpose of a...

Commentary

Guest Commentary: Breaking barriers: The case for diversifying and supporting the teaching workforce

December 15, 2025

Share Tweet Email By Chanelle Williams “You just get it. You know what it’s like to be...

SUNrise

Why doing good also makes us feel good, during the holidays and beyond

December 10, 2025

Share Tweet Email FILE – A volunteer waves to a student as she waits in line at...

Fur Babies Rule!

How to help your dog be happier at every stage of life

September 3, 2025

Share Tweet Email BPT If you’ve had the privilege to welcome a dog into your household, you...

Health

Councilmember Dr. Nina Ahmad speaks at the ACE Your Health forum about health equity and poverty

November 24, 2025

Share Tweet Email Dr. Ahmad speaking at the conference.Photo: Napoleon F. Kingcade By Napoleon F. Kingcade Inside...

Home and Garden

Five tips to get your home ready for holiday hosting

December 2, 2025

Share Tweet Email FAMILY FEATURESWhether you’re planning a cozy dinner with friends or a full-blown holiday gathering,...

The Philadelphia Sunday Sun Staff